The surge in gold prices, driven by escalating geopolitical uncertainties, has drawn a cautionary note from the European Central Bank (ECB), which warns that the ongoing gold rush may pose risks to broader financial stability.
Gold, the world’s most trusted safe-haven asset, recently hit an intraday record of $3,500 per ounce on April 22 and currently trades near $3,400. This marks an impressive gain of roughly 30% since the start of the year and about 65% since early 2024—significantly outperforming many other asset classes, including major stock indices.
Structural Vulnerabilities in Gold Markets
In its latest Financial Stability Report, the ECB highlights that commodity markets, including gold, suffer from several structural weaknesses. These include a high concentration of trading among a few large firms, extensive use of leverage, and a lack of transparency due to predominantly over-the-counter (OTC) trading.
Such conditions, the ECB warns, could trigger serious market disruptions during periods of extreme geopolitical or economic stress. Market participants with heavy exposure to gold derivatives might face significant margin calls or encounter difficulties in procuring and delivering physical gold tied to derivative contracts, potentially leading to substantial losses.
A particular concern is the rising preference among investors for gold contracts that require physical delivery. The number of such contracts registered for delivery has reached record levels, peaking in January 2025 at the highest point since mid-2007.
Potential Supply Bottlenecks and Bank Exposure
Under typical market conditions, investors do not intend to take physical delivery of gold. Instead, they trade contracts to speculate or hedge positions, usually closing out contracts before delivery dates. However, if a large group of participants—potentially including entities acting on behalf of hostile states—demand physical delivery simultaneously, banks and financial institutions could be forced to source significant quantities of gold on short notice.
This sudden demand could create supply bottlenecks, sharply driving up gold prices and exposing banks to heavy losses. Although the ECB stops short of naming specific sectors, its analysis clearly targets the banking industry, which holds substantial exposure to gold derivatives, often in transactions involving foreign counterparties.
As of March 2025, the gross value of gold derivative contracts held by investors in the eurozone reached approximately €1 trillion—a nearly 60% increase over five months. The market’s opacity adds to the uncertainty, with banks acting as counterparties in about half of these contracts, alongside investment funds and hedge funds.
Shifts in Physical Gold Flows
Meanwhile, physical gold shipments have been increasingly moving from London to New York. This shift is partly driven by traders seeking to preempt potential U.S. tariffs on gold imports and by a slight price premium for gold in New York compared to London.
Typically, London serves as the main hub for physical gold storage and wholesale transactions, while futures contracts trade primarily on the New York Stock Exchange’s Comex platform, where prices generally align closely.
Currently, there are no tariffs on gold imports, and market tensions have eased. However, the ECB cautions that under extreme future scenarios, stresses in the gold market could cascade into broader financial turbulence.
Related topics:
- India Surpasses China in Gold Purchases, Buying 51% More in Three Months
- Qilu Bank Enhances Support for Small Businesses with Innovative Financial Tools
- Bitcoin Poised for a Surge Amid Gold’s Delivery Delays, Expert Claims
